Guns

5 Best AR-15 Piston Uppers: Tested & Ranked

When it comes to optimizing your AR-15, choosing the right upper receiver can make all the difference. Piston-driven upper receivers, which use a piston system to cycle the AR-15, have become increasingly popular due to their ability to run cleaner and cooler than their DI system counterparts.

So, what is the best AR-15 piston upper receiver? In this article, we list the best AR-15 piston upper receivers based on our own experience. We also take a look at the main benefits of using a piston upper, as well as the factors you should consider when buying one.

AR-15 Piston Uppers


What Is An AR-15 Piston Upper?

An AR-15 piston upper utilizes a piston system to cycle the AR-15. Piston uppers function differently than traditional uppers, as they don’t use a direct impingement (DI) system. The main difference is noted in how the gas channels in the upper.


What Distinguishes AR Piston Uppers From Direct Impingement Uppers?

AR piston uppers differ from direct impingement uppers in their gas channeling mechanisms, specifically where and how the gas is utilized to operate the action.

In a direct impingement system, the gas is directed straight back through a tube to the bolt carrier. In a piston system, this gas pushes a piston that in turn drives the bolt carrier.


What Are the Main Benefits Of Using A Piston AR Upper?

A piston AR upper has three main benefits: cleaner operation, cooler running, and adjustability.

  • Cleaner Operation: Since gases are not dumped directly into the bolt carrier, there’s less fouling in the action. This leads to less maintenance for the shooter – a major factor if you’re someone who doesn’t clean their AR-15 uppers as regularly as they should.
  • Cooler Running: Piston systems typically run cooler than DI systems, which can increase component lifespan. This also allows you to have more intense shooting sessions with your AR-15 without the risk of the AR-15 running too hot and potentially damaging the barrel.
  • Adjustability: Many piston systems, like those mentioned in this article, allow for adjustable gas settings, which is beneficial when using suppressors or when firing different ammunition loads.

Best AR-15 Piston-Driven Upper Receivers

The best AR-15 piston-driven upper receivers are listed below.

Lasso Brag

1) POF P-415 Edge

Editors #1 Pick
POF P-415 Edge
4.9

Includes: $86.00 Off w/ Free S&H

Shop on OpticsPlanet Shop on PSA
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting us - we really appreciate it!

Synonymous with reliability, the POF P-415 Edge has been crafted with the highest standards in mind. Its anodized black finish and M-LOK gun rail emphasize its premium construction. You’ll have no trouble hitting your mark with a solid barrel length of 16.5 inches and a Triple Port muzzle device for efficient gas dispersion.

POF P-415 Edge

The POF has a handguard length of 14.5 inches, providing ample space for grip and attachments like lights and optics. Overall, of all the upper receivers I tested, this upper gave me the most enjoyable experience, offering a highly efficient gas piston system and immense durability and accuracy.

While a price of $1,439 is inaccessible to some, the POF does offer immense value, and I would recommend the POF to anyone who can afford it.


2) Primary Weapon Systems MK1 MOD 2

Runner Up
Primary Weapon Systems MK1 Mod 2
4.8

Includes: Special pricing for Officers, First Responders, and Military.

Shop on PA Shop on PSA
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting us - we really appreciate it!

Renowned for its rock-solid build, the PWS MK1 MOD 2 just resonates with strength and precision. Its 3-setting adjustable gas block and inclusion of the Radian Raptor Charging Handle are the two standout features for me.

High-volume shooters should take note of this upper receiver. Its gas operating system makes it adept at efficiently cycling between ammunition types or use of a suppressor while maintaining optimal gas flow.

Primary Weapon Systems MK1 MOD 2

If you want a versatile upper that functions best with suppressors, the PWS is the best piston upper for you.


3) Faxon Firearms ARAK-21 Upper Receiver

Faxon Firearms ARAK-21 Upper Receiver
4.7

Includes: $95.92 Off w/ Free S&H

Shop on OpticsPlanet
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting us - we really appreciate it!

Faxon Firearms’s ARAK-21 upper is well built. It is designed for marksmen who prioritize adaptability. I especially liked the ambidextrous features – adding to the versatility of the upper receiver. Built from aircraft-grade 6061-T6 aluminum, this upper receiver offers superior durability.

Furthermore, the M4-style quad rail caters to those who value endless customization options. And the non-reciprocating, foldable charging handle can be easily relocated without the need for tools.


4) Adams Arms P1 MOE AR-Platform 5.56x45mm NATO 16″

Adams Arms P1 Complete Upper AR-Platform
3.5

Includes: $50.01 Off w/ Free S&H

Shop on OpticsPlanet Shop on PSA
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting us - we really appreciate it!

The P-series is renowned for its innovative design. One of its standout features is the short-stroke free floating piston system, which ensures efficient extraction of excess gas, allowing smooth, consistent, and reliable cycling of rounds.

Another feat of innovation in the P1 is the self-cleaning feature of the barrel and bolt carrier group, meaning less maintenance and more shooting time! Overall, at $680, the P1 offers immense value with some innovative design features.


5) Superlative Arms Adjustable Gas Piston Kit

Best Kit
Superlative Arms AR15 .750in Solid Adjustable Piston System
3.5

Includes: 10% Off — Free 2 Day Shipping

Shop on OpticsPlanet Shop on Brownells
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting us - we really appreciate it!

What sets the SA adjustable gas piston kit apart is its patented adjustment system, situated outside of the block to prevent contamination and ensure the longevity of your AR upper. It also ensures consistent performance even when you’re pounding away round after round.

Furthermore, the gas adjustment screw design guarantees there’s no erosion or seizing, which is quite common under heavy-use ARs. At $289.99, the SA piston kit is our budget-friendly option for the list. If you need a piston upper that can withstand numerous rounds and wet conditions, this is the AR upper to get!


What Factors Should Be Considered Before Buying An AR-15 Piston Upper?

The most important factors you should consider before buying an AR-15 piston upper include compatibility, adjustability, price/budget, and manufacturer reputation.

Before buying a new upper, ensure it is compatible with your existing AR-15 setup, more specifically, your AR-15 lower. The last thing you want is to buy a new upper only to find it isn’t compatible with your lower – trust me, it happens.

Next, double-check whether the piston upper gas system can be tuned to different settings. This is not a necessity, but it adds to the versatility of the upper. Who knows, maybe you’ll want a suppressor on your AR-15.

As you might have picked up when reading the five best piston uppers, piston systems tend to be more expensive than DI systems. Set a budget and find the best within that range.

Finally, stick with reputable brands known for quality and reliability. It doesn’t help if you find the bargain of a lifetime, only to have a broken AR-15 upper a month after buying it. Remember, cheap buying is often expensive buying!


Does Piston AR Upper Affect The Accessories That Could Be Mounted?

No, a piston AR-15 upper does not affect the accessories you can mount on your AR-15. While the core operation differs from a DI system’s, the external configuration (mounting rails and handguard) of piston AR uppers remains largely similar to DI uppers.

This means most AR-15 modifications, like optics and handguards, are universally compatible, even if you convert a DI to a piston system.


Can You Convert A DI AR-15 Into A Piston System?

You can convert a DI AR-15 into a piston system using a conversion kit. The best AR-15 for you is one that offers you the best possible user experience, so if you believe a piston system is the upper system for you, then you can easily convert a DI to a piston system. This also allows you to experience both systems without investing in a new rifle.


Which Is The Best AR-15 Conversion Kit?

The best AR-15 piston upper conversion kit is the Superlative Arms Adjustable Gas Piston Kit. It enables you to swap the entire upper out. It comes with an excellent adjustable gas block. You can also get kits for Carbine, Mid, or Rifle-Length guns as your needs dictate.


Frequently Asked Questions

Is a piston upper more reliable than a direct impingement system?

Piston uppers are more reliable than a DI system. This is because they tend to run cleaner and cooler, translating to longer intervals between cleanings and greater reliability in harsh conditions.

Are piston uppers compatible with most AR-15 lowers?

Yes, piston uppers are compatible with most AR-15 lowers. Piston uppers are designed to be a drop-in replacement for a DI upper, so they should easily fit standard AR-15 lowers.

The Bottom Line

Choosing between a piston-driven or direct impingement AR-15 is largely a matter of personal preference. However, despite their higher price tag, piston-driven AR uppers do offer advantages over DI systems. Therefore, incorporating a piston-driven AR upper receiver into your AR-15 ensures not only a performance enhancement but also a testament to the evolution of firearm technology. Ultimately, the best piston-driven AR-15 upper for you comes down to your use case, budget, and performance requirements.

About the author

Charles Neser

I'm a life long hunter & gun lover. Currently pursuing my Master's Degree (M.Sc.) in Animal Nutrition at University of the Free State.

Leave a Comment